Experienced Professionals

InSightful Solutions

Michelle Pray

Niche President

I am the Consumer Services Niche President, which includes Social Services Non Profits and Restaurants, Bars, and Taverns. I have ownership for the underwriting, business development and distribution management for these areas of focus. I have over 25 years of industry experience. Prior to working with ProSight I was with Fireman’s Fund Insurance Co. and Allianz in a variety of senior underwriting leadership positions and have successfully led underwriting teams across the country. I graduated from California State University Fullerton where I received my Bachelor’s degree in Business Management.

The ProSight Difference

We create unrivaled value for our customers by exceeding expectations in everything we do. We accomplish this based on our unique performance culture and a desire to succeed at uncommon challenges.

Partnering Only with Exclusive Agents

We partner exclusively with a select number of agents who share our vision of delivering value to customers through superior expertise.

Excellent Financial Strength

The underwriting members of the ProSight Specialty Insurance (ProSight) group are rated “A-” (Excellent) by A.M. Best.


Get in touch

Contact Options



(973) 532-1900

Mailing address
ProSight Specialty Insurance
412 Mount Kemble Ave.
Suite 300C
Morristown, NJ 07960

Get a Quote